Instacart

(This post may include affiliate links. You can read about our affiliate policy here.)

What: Instacart enlists side hustlers to shop for and deliver groceries

Expected pay: $10 – $20 per hour

Husl $core: $$$

Where: National

Requirements:

• Be over the age of 18
• Be able to lift 50 pound packages without assistance
• Be eligible to work in the U.S.
• Pass a background check

If you are signing up to be a full-service shopper, you also need a car, auto insurance, 2 years of driving experience and a smart phone.

Want to shop for Instacart?

1. Click here to sign up
2. Enter your phone number to receive the app download link
3. Download the app and create your profile
4. Start earning

Instacart Review: 

Instacart, one of the early entrants to the gig economy, has gone through its ups and downs. The site has always enlisted freelancers to shop for groceries for people who want deliveries. During the darkest days of the pandemic, demand for this service was so high that customers were waving big tips at drivers to get their attention.

Unfortunately, the site allowed these customers to rip away the driver tips after the deliveries were done, which understandably caused an uproar. Driver tips remain a significant portion of pay for independent contractors delivering for Instacart. However, we’re hearing less about these tips being ripped away post-delivery. And, in recently testing the site as a customer, we saw the option of boosting a tip post-delivery, but no clear way to retroactively take away tips. Dishonest customers may still find a way, but it appears to be less of a problem.

Employee or contractor

Now the site has morphed again and has two different choices for people who like shopping for groceries. You can sign up to be an in-store shopper, who do no deliveries and are employees of Instacart. Or you can sign up to be a “full-service shopper.” Full-service shoppers are independent contractors, who use their own cars, insurance and gas and are paid by the gig.  

In-store shoppers will earn at least minimum wage and can be scheduled for up to 29 hours a week. These individuals shop for and package orders, which will be picked up by delivery drivers.

Full-service shoppers work whenever they choose to. When they sign onto the app, the app alerts them to pending orders, which they can decide to fill or pass. The order has information about where and what you’re shopping for and how much the order pays. Drivers also can get tips, which Instacart encourages, but does not require.

Theoretically, the in-store shopper earns less per hour. However, after accounting for taxes, insurance, gas and other expenses, pay is likely to work out to just over minimum wage for “full-service” independent contractors, too.

Recommendations

Demand for grocery deliveries remains brisk. If you like this type of work, Instacart is the market leader, likely to have the most gigs available. (If you want to shop for Instacart, you can sign up here.) You can also work with Shipt, which promises nearly identical pay and terms.

However, we suggest you also sign up with a site called Dumpling. Dumpling allows you to essentially run your own shopping and delivery business, building up your own clientele and setting your own rates and fees. You pay them a small fee to provide you with a credit card (that advances money for your shopping trips) and billing services.

What their drivers say: From Indeed:

“Great flexible be your own boss job that’s easy to learn, but comes with highs and lows depending on shopping volume and time of year. Its always available if you want quick money based on how fast you can work.”

“Great for a side hustle but that’s about it. Flexible with the schedule but the pay should be much better for the amount of time it takes to complete some orders.”

“I used to be so thankful for Instacart three years ago because it allowed flexibility in my schedule. I am a single mother and a job like this has been a blessing, and a curse as well. It has put a lot of wear and tear on my car and placed me in risky situations. They used to be pretty good, I averaged $20-$28 an hour but now I’m lucky if I get $18-$20 an hour. That is not even counting the taxes and gas.”

Need better pay

“Horrible pay and difficult to get problems resolved. Their online support is awful! Most customers don’t tip well, especially when they order heavy items. If you want a service, you need to compensate your shopper, otherwise, go get your own groceries!”

“Over the last five years shopper/driver pay has decreased significantly. This job no longer pays a living wage in most areas.”

“Orders are hard to come by now and your pay even worse. you could spend a good 10 hours at times and only make 60-90$. before you could make that in a matter of hours.”

(from Reddit)

“The new pay model essentially eliminated tips (60% of my earnings). I worked long hours during October of last year and made around $20/hr factoring gas into the equation. The new pay model knocked me down to less than $10/hr and I only put up with that for a few days before finding a better delivery service.”

“The hourly guarantee is calculated by the WEEK, not the day. For example, my zone has a $12/hr guarantee until I hit 50 batches. (It doesn’t tell you that. I had to call shopper happiness to find out the number of batches before I lose my guarantee.)

Let’s say I work the following hours and make the following earnings:

Mon – 10 hours : $90

Tues – 6 hours : $30

Wed – 8 hours : $120

Thur – 8 hours : $40

Fri – 8 hours : $144

Sat – 12 hours : $180

Sun – 8 hours : $160.

That’s 60 hours for the week and $764 in earnings, meaning I made a total of $12.73/hr, exceeding the guarantee and getting no extra money, even though I had single days that made far less than the guarantee. If we changed that a little and said that the Friday wasn’t nearly so good, I made $100 less ($44). So my hours were still 60 but my earnings were $664, meaning I only made $11.07/hr. Since I made less than $12/hr for the week, they would give me money until I hit the $12/hr for the 60 hours I worked, adding $56 to my account to bring my weekly earnings to $720.”

“Fun? Hahahaha. Yeah, right.”

[In response to a question from a Houston newbie, who asked about making decent earnings when working very part-time:] 

“If you don’t work 30 hours during the week you’re not on the early schedule….there’s a good chance that you’re not gonna get any hours unless you constantly look at the app to check to see if people dropped any.”

“It’s total bullshit that they make people work 30 hours a week to get on the schedule and the way they do weekends is bullshit too…some people can’t work weekends. It’s very un-flexible…I cannot for the life of me figure out why they want to do it that way. Seems like a lot of people would like to do this job as a side gig for extra money. They pretty much want full-time employees.”

Updated 5/3/2022